Sunday, June 16, 2019

Student-Designed Writing Prompts

By Natalie Elschlager

Sometime in March this school year, the Creative Writing kiddos were comfortable enough to stretch their abilities even further. Out of the blue one day, several students began to express an interest in developing their own writing prompts/activities for the class. I had to let go of the reins. Honestly, it was easy to do. Their confidence in their writing was palpable. We decided to start with developing student-designed prompts.

The Lesson

Each student generated 2-5 of their own writing prompts-- any style, any format, and length, etc. Then, the class was divided into small groups where they shared their prompt ideas. It took about 15-20 minutes to provide and receive feedback from peers. From there, students returned to their seats. Based upon what they learned from their classmates and their personal judgement, they narrowed their focus on one prompt from their list.

Meanwhile, I had already posted a blank Google Doc to our Google Classroom. When they felt totally ready, each student typed their prompt in the document. In order to avoid a feeling of being overwhelmed by too many options yet maintain a certain amount of flexibility, we voted on 5 prompts to tackle straight away-- just 5 from our master list. Here are our top five:


  1. Write a poem about your feelings towards a close family member. Make sure there are at least two stanzas.
  2. Write a poem about someone in the class--it doesn’t matter who--but don’t say their name.
  3. Six word horror story (write 3-5 of these).
  4. Design a shaped poem specific to the subject of your poem.
  5. Everyone has their expiration date on their arm when they’re born. You’re past your due date. Write a short story.

(Author’s note: I really love the variety here! Look at #2...big time relationship builder.)

As for the remaining prompts, we were able to revisit them in a variety of ways: bell ringers/warm-ups, journaling, and for those moments when we had additional time to fill in the period. With this, each student felt the value in their contribution.

Big Take-Ways

  • Equal contribution from all students
  • Community Building: collaboration; discussion, peer-editing
  • Each student is recognized for their idea
  • Flexibility and choice for the writer
  • Assortment of writing prompts
  • Promotes creativity!

Final Word

If you can sense your students are ready for this challenge, essentially designing their own writing lesson (wow!), I say go for it...let loose. What I found most interesting and rewarding is how this simple “flipping the switch” recharged my writers at a time of the year where I think we all needed a little reboot, helping enhance our resilience and stamina in our writing journey together.

River of Grass: College Sudents' Found Poetry

Shared by Laurie J. Kemp

For almost 10 years now I have been teaching a required course at the local university. The university vision, mission, and guiding principles incorporate coursework about sustainability to "prepare students, faculty, and staff to be engaged citizens and leaders of the green economy." No matter what major a student selects, every undergraduate must complete a couple of required courses in civic engagement and sustainability. I teach the course on sustainability, which also incorporates local ecology and sense of place.

Needless to say, I have my share of students who are less than thrilled about the mandatory coursework they sometimes feel does not apply to their major, and worse, is of no interest to them. Sadly, some of them cannot be swayed. However, by the end of the course many of them begin to understand that all people in all majors can benefit from understanding concepts around sustainability and the value of their local environment and the natural world.

In any event, with all of the heavy reading in the course (there is lots of it), most textbook and informational reading, something different happens when my students encounter an excerpt from Marjory Stoneman Douglas' The Everglades: River of Grass. Because Douglas was a journalist and a writer, her work reads a lot differently than the other readings. There is a richness in the sensory descriptions and many of my students from the math, science and engineering majors struggle with the literary tone and structure. I am pretty sure most of them quit reading before they ever got halfway through.

A couple of years ago, I decided a good way to engage students from the various colleges and to add a language and humanities component previously lacking in the course, would be to focus on the literary contribution of the work and the homage to the Florida Everglades. Thus, my lessons on found poetry were born! I have done this individually and collaboratively, and because of the nature of the course I teach, we focus on sense of place. I will include commentary and variations along with the steps and the work of some of my students.


A College Found Poetry Lesson with The Everglades: River of Grass by Marjory Stoneman Douglas:

Step 1: 
The course text collection includes the first chapter of the book called "The Nature of the Everglades." The chapter has sections focused on The Grass; The Water; The Rock, and The River, as well as two sections called The River of Time, and Life on the Rock. Each of these is chock full of rich detailed and dynamic descriptions of the flora and fauna so unique to The Everglades.

The first time I tried this assignment I asked students to read with no particular section in mind. In subsequent lessons, I have tried assigning sections or asking everyone to read all of it, and asking afterward for students to select one section that resonated strongly with them. Best part about these lessons is that there really are no rules! The key to how you assign the text is how you plan to engage the students in the writing activity that follows. My students read it before coming to class.

Step 2: 
This step can happen in tandem with Step 1, or if you are focused on multiple reads and close reading in your class, can stand alone as an actual next step to Step 1. Again, I have done it both ways. Either way, the task is to identify (by annotating, underlining, highlighting) while they are reading, or by going back and jotting on sticky notes or notecards, words, phrases, or pieces of description or information that resonate with them.

Depending on your purpose, you can ask for descriptive language, important information, sounds or verbs, etc. My courses is less about knowledge transmission or acquisition, and more about exposure to new ideas and experiences, so I leave the door wide open for quite literally, anything that resonates with them or strikes them as noteworthy. You can provide a target number of items if you wish, but I prefer not to.

*I find the sticky note or notecard method works best because students are able to move their text around for the next step. Even better is to have them annotate while they read, and then re-read and jot on the notecards or sticky notes. You can even have them write their text on paper and cut them into strips. Do whatever works in the time and space you have.

*I have done this two different ways. Sometimes I tell the students up front what they will be doing and why they are writing down the words and phrases. Other times, I leave them wondering. Sometimes not knowing what the purpose is at the start keeps them from editing and censoring themselves as they collect from the reading.

Step 3:
Here is when you have the option of using an individual or collaborative writing exercise. You can ask students to do this on their own (this was necessary as an online activity in several of my college courses) or as a collaborative group, which is my favorite implementation. I have done it both ways, but the collaborative aspect of group writing helps build classroom community, and it's fun!

Students bring their notecards or sticky notes to a group. They lay them all out on a table or desks in front of them, and work together to arrange their text into a shared poem. I often have to remind them they don't have to use every one of each individual's notecards, and inevitably someone asks if they can add any of their own words. I have never allowed that, but again you choose the rules! I do allow them to pluralize or singularize words and change tense and pronouns as needed. The poem can be in any form the students choose.

*I had some photos of my students working through this process, but can't seem to dig them up. It's quite the sight, especially when your groups get really into it, and many of them do!

Step 4:
Groups or individuals revise their poems and share them. If we completed them in class, I require the groups to read them aloud and I always require them to post them in Canvas (the online LMS used by our university). In the end, it is so interesting to see what they hyper focused on or what aspects of the text resonate with them. I also require students to reflect on the process and how it contributed to their comprehension and perception of the author and the text. It's really interesting to see how different students process the same text.

Here is some of their work:

Fiery Glade

Wetness that is sweet among salt
tiny hidden blossoms, luminous in the darkness,
give way to mile high pillars of orange light, roily tangerine
spears thrust into the burning brass

rolling clouds of heavy cream against a hyacinth sky
thin screaming hordes bend in the west wind
they bow, they burn
the fierce fire, lord, power and first cause over the Everglades

***

The Evercycle

Half way down that thrusting sea-bound peninsula.
Grass and water together make the river.
Its stringy and grainy dullness glitters with the myriad unrotted silica points, like glass dust.
To try and make ones way among these impenetrable tufts is to be cut off from air.
Clouds fill with their steely haze and leave only outline of the visible world.
Water falls solid, in sheets, in cascades.
The sawgrass and all those acres of green growing things draw up the water within their cells, use it, and breathe it out again.
***

"like the birds, he is everywhere"

the great pointed paw
of which it marks the end,
the question was at once,
where do you begin?

subtlety and diversity,
a crowd of changing forms,
of thrusting teeming life;

vast glittering openness—
the bright where the color
of the water and the color
of the sky become one,
spreading and flowing
on its true course southward.

at the horizon, they
become velvet—
taller and denser in
the dark soil of
its own death,
superb monotony.

the glitter of rising water
will be everywhere,
the foundation stuff
of the world—
time, the vastest river,
carries us and all life forward.
here, the rain is everything.

***

At the End of the World

Where the grass and the water are there
And the dew falls,
Where one sinks in mud and water
And neighborhoods form,
These impenetrable tufts
Beaten down by the sun,
Hold no weight.

Forces of the season
Balanced, like scales
Are green with thick-stemmed waterweeds,
White marly water
And glowing yellow.
Here at the end of the world.

***

The Everglades

There are no other Everglades in the world.
The Everglades, El Laguno del Espiritu Santo.
Beginning at lake Okeechobee,
Crisp lake waves.
The winds shatter the reflections.
The mystery of the Everglades,
is enduring, so hostile, so simple.
Land breezes and sea breezes
Coming from the west.
In the luminous unseen dark,
Yet moon flowers opened acres
Of flat white blossoms, cloud white,
Foam white, and still.

***

Following upward and downward
The Everglades curve grandly in the limestone
All this end of the peninsula is a country that the sea has conquered and has never left
The blue of the sky is caught down there among the grass stems
Flashing back their red and emerald and diamond lights to the revealed glory of the sun in splendor
Here the rain falls more powerfully and logically than anywhere else upon the temperate mainland of the United States
They are a world in themselves

Saturday, June 15, 2019

Mad Lib Warm-Ups

Mad Lib Warm-Ups

by Helen Sadler

I teach a creative writing course which has all three levels in middle school together in one class.  This past semester a 6th grade boy started a mad lib activity at the beginning of class that became a regular feature.

We always begin each writing class with a ten minute freewrite: lights off and a few prompts up on the screen. After a couple weeks of the usual freewriting, a boy began to create a story leaving out specific parts.  He would then sit on the author's stool in the front of the room and ask the other writers to provide the details, calling on them as they raised their hands. What is cool about this is that he had to tell them if he needed a noun, adjective, or verb: it reinforced these parts of speech without any work on my part! He also would have to identify if the noun had to be a person, place, or thing. At first this started out slowly, with only a few participating, but eventually everyone got more involved and wanted to offer ideas.


Mad Lib Shell by Isabela


After the story was all filled in, a reading of it would take place, to smiles and giggles.  We might talk about correct usage of things like verbs, but in general this was just considered a warm-up and a way to build community by collaborating on the end product.

Mad Lib filled in by student suggestions
Eventually other students began to write their own mad lib shells, and taking turns calling on others to fill in their stories. After several weeks of this, a 7th grade girl used song lyrics, leaving out specific words in order to "rewrite" the song and change its meaning.  This caught on and was used by writers as more and more got involved.

Leaving room for student innovation is the key to building a writing community.  This second period class taught me a lot about being open to whatever works best for the group as a whole, and allowing them to bend and shape it as they saw fit.


Song lyrics used for Mad Lib, Twenty-One Pilots being a favorite








Scribble Stories

Scribble Stories

by Helen Sadler

Here is a fun, collaborative, and easy activity to build community in the classroom. I tend to use this when I have some time to fill before a holiday or during testing times when the schedules get messed up.

The scribble story begins by creating groups of about 4-5 people.  Each person in the group has one plain piece of copy paper, as well as a marker. Each group member's marker color should be different.

First, the group decides how they will send the paper around the circle they've created.

Next, each group member draws one line/squiggle/shape on the paper.  ONE.

They pass on to the next person, who adds on. As the papers go around, a unique image should begin to appear on each paper, based on the contributions of each member.

As the images start to emerge, the group then begins to figure out what kind of story they can tell from the images, as well as deciding what else they may need to add to each drawing to make it more complete.

As writers get to this point, I bring them a large piece of chart paper and glue.  They glue down the pictures in the order they go, and write their story in marker in large lettering next to it.  I tell them to be sure to attend to the basics of story -- some kind of conflict is being resolved.  I also encourage dialogue so the characters have some life to them. These are very short stories, so a little can go a long way.

I didn't have large enough chart paper, so they worked on two and taped together
This activity produces lots of laughter as the kids try to make their stories cohesive.  The next step, of course, is to present.



The Scribble Story has been a good standby for me for many years, but I know it has greater possibilities than I have allowed. There are two ways I see using this more effectively in the future: first -- do it at the beginning of school to build community quickly.  Second -- do it again later in the year after we've studied things like character, plot, setting, and require them to be more deliberate in adding these elements.

Either way, this is always a winner, and makes a good wall display.

Happy writing!

Monday, May 13, 2019

Content Area Specific Found Poetry

By Natalie Elschlager

Found Poetry is one of my favorite, go-to formats whenever the occasion strikes me. Like the time our school had a pep rally and the normal schedule was totally thrown off-- found poetry to the rescue! That afternoon, we printed two sets of lyrics from our favorite songs and created original pieces.


Also, FP is extremely flexible. It can be done independently, with partners, in teams, etc. in any content area. In the past, I have had my students create found poetry from famous speeches, such as King's "I Have a Dream". We have designed found poems from pages in novels or scenes from plays. It's an excellent distributive summarizing tool, as well.

In this lesson, I wanted to challenge my Creative Writing students while also promoting 'writing to learn' in ALL content areas. The idea being students can further study/review a content-specific concept all while honing and increasing their writing practice. It can be done! We even managed to write a poem about Trig....TRIG! Yes, MATH! Insanity, right?;-) The lesson is detailed in the video below. Feel free to steal, tweek, and implement found poetry into your lessons ASAP. 

Writing Skills
Academics Skills
Social Skills
form; structure; design
annotating; 
marking the text
collaboration
language; word choice
pulling; citing text
peer review; feedback
poetic techniques
composition
publication



Sunday, April 21, 2019

Write to Be Heard

Teaching Reflection by Annmarie Ferry



After an emotionally draining week, I sat down at my work station, talking myself into doing something productive when all I really wanted to do was log a sick day and go home.  As I perused my emails--some spam from former students' parents, a fairly regular occurrence in the past month or so--a subject line grabbed my attention. Instead of the telltale spam lines, it actually had the student's name. This particular student's parents advocated for him like nobody's business, and we quickly formed an alliance, one that aimed to boost *Tim's confidence.

I wanted to share with you because you believed in him...it began. I truly did believe in this kid, even when he tried his hardest to convince me he couldn't meet my expectations. 

Tim signed a very good music publishing deal with a music company in LAHe is writing music and lyrics for famous artists and also still pursuing his own music. Every hair on my arms was standing on end as tears welled up. Like I said, it had been an emotional week, but who am I kidding? I get choked up anytime I hear something awesome about a former student. 

He always did well in writing, and he proudly remembers the award you nominated him for.  Wait. What? I think back. I did nominate him for a school-wide English III subject area award that he ended up winning, but I can't believe he actually remembers that. 

You changed his life! Thank you. 

I read that last line 100 times, tears now streaming down my cheeks. I would have never fathomed a small gesture like that could have such a lasting impact. 

It's not often in life we get to see or hear about the influence we have had on people. But, when we do, it's so affirming. 

That affirmation could not have come at a better time.

started reflecting upon that English III class. All of the students assigned to me had Individual Education Plans (IEPs), and many of their deficits had to do with written language skills.  They came to me convinced they were not good writers because of past standardized writing tests on which they did not score proficient. Ditto the state reading assessments. Trying to convince this group of jaded 16-17 year olds that they could write was no easy feat. 

I knew the best way to do that was to have them write. Every single day.They wrote short responses to thought questions. They wrote dialectic journals. They wrote personal responses to literature. They wrote poems, including my favorite, the found poem. They wrote letters. They wrote speeches. They wrote mini-memoirs. They wrote short stories. They wrote RAFT responses. They wrote some essays, but not formulaic 5-paragraph essays. In fact, I banned 5-paragraph essays. 

"Give me 4 or 6 paragraphs," I told them as they all stared at me in shock.

"We don't know how to write any other way," they whined.

I assured them I'd help them through the process of breaking the mold. "Plus, I don't like odd numbers," I responded with a wink.

What I got that year was some fantastic 4-paragraph essays with well-developed body paragraphs, not the requisite 5 sentences they were used to. It wasn't easy, but the learning process never is--if you're truly learning and growing. 

More than that, I was treated to some really deep and insightful writing.  First, we had to establish a safe space, a supportive community of writers. We did that through writing and sharing that writing. I had to be the one to start that, to make myself vulnerable right off the bat. I sat amongst them and wrote while they wrote. Then, I plopped my writing under the document camera and let them critique it. At first they were hesitant to give me feedback, but they began to open up to the idea. 

Some of them jumped at the chance to share their writing while others needed more time to put their words out there. Some of them never did read their words out loud, and I didn't forced it. They shared their thoughts in writing, and for them, that was an act of bravery in and of itself. 

These kids just wanted to--needed to--be heard, to have a voice in a world that didn't seem to value what they had to say. I don't think any one person told them they didn't count. I believe it was years of being labeled as "learning disabled" and falling short on state tests that made them feel less than. 

The writing they produced that year was all the empirical evidence I needed that I was on the right track. I watched as they blossomed and became more confident in sharing their thoughts and ideas. 

That is the real power in writing. Not everyone is a natural-born writer, just as I'm not a talented painter or singer. But, by applying a growth mindset and providing ample opportunities to just write, writers will be born. Their craft will be honed. 

Above all, writing gives everyone a voice. A voice that begs to be heard. A voice that deserves to be heard. 



*name changed to protect student's identity

Saturday, April 20, 2019

Community in 360 Degrees

360 Degree Writing

Strategy presented by Helen Sadler 


Observation is one of the key principles of being a writer. In order to teach my writers how to observe, we do the 360 Degree poem.

This is best done outdoors, if possible, but can be done in the classroom.

Recently, I took my Creative Writing class outside on a gorgeous Florida morning, and asked them to have their notebooks in hand, to stand facing a direction, and think of a clock.  We started at 12:00, writing down a list of everything in front of us we could see. I also asked them to include anything they hear or smell. Then we moved to 1:00, 2:00, etc., moving like the hands on a clock, until we reached 12:00 again. This provides a list to work with.

We then sat down at the picnic tables, and worked on circling the images we liked the best. The goal was to form these images into a poem. The entire exercise, including reading a few poems aloud, only takes about 30 minutes. It gets us out of the usual environment, and that alone adds to the feeling of community. It also teaches a lesson in observation -- without a doubt, we are all basically looking at the same things. But what one person ignores, someone else writes down. It shows us that not everyone sees things the same way, or places the same importance on what they observe.

Here is an poem example from a girl named Sophia. She read her poem right away, saying that this activity had given her new appreciation for Florida.

Do you hear the singing birds,
the swishing grass,
the rattling branches?
Do you see the calm little bird,
the lush green grass,
the purple wildflowers?
Do the dandelions soar to you like 
a lone eagle in the sky?
Does the battered palm tell you
stories of revenge on the wind?
Do you smell the new grass or 
the small pine tree?
This is Florida; there are thistles,
they don't scratch you.
I am like the small bug skittering
at my feet, tiny in this great
state of beauty.






I created this process based on the idea "Outdoor Poems" found on page 115 of Poetry Everywhere by Jack Collom and Sheryl Noethe (1994).

Practice What You Teach: Building Classroom Community with Writing

Professional Development Session Presented at   ASCD Conference on Teaching Excellence  Orlando, Florida - June 2019 Learning Objective...